The Church of Baskin-Robbins
Aug. 3rd, 2009 12:41 pmRecently, I was chatting with an acquaintance of mine who is a Catholic. While trying not to pry, I was rather curious as to why he, a gay man, still chose to subscribe to being Catholic. Ultimately, he is ok being gay and Catholic because he believes he is fine the way he is. I too agree that he is perfectly fine the way he is, and that he is not “flawed” by being a big ol’ queer. But where I disagree is on the Catholic part. I respect his choice. I just don’t agree with it. After all, Catholicism is pretty staunch in its unwavering view that it is NOT ok to be gay. And that is where I take issue – not just with the religion, but with the idea of anyone choosing to stay given the terms and conditions.
I know I have posted on this concept lots in the past, so I’ll just summarize things here. I do believe there was a historical Jesus – a very mortal human being. Free-thinking, and radical, he taught and practiced kindness, ethics, and morality – a noble cause indeed. The victim of an incredibly harsh and cruel political murder, he inspired countless over the centuries – sadly not always in the best way. I think I would have gotten along rather well with Jesus. And if we could span the centuries together, we would probably both fight hard against many of the churches that came along after him.
I have my dear husband to thank for opening my eyes to the fact that not all forms of Christianity are bad. Being a woad-coverin’, devout ex-Catholic myself, I grew up believing that there was Catholicism (the One True Faith), and all the other flavors, which were some variety of the same thing. Protestant was Catholic Light. Methodist was Diet Catholic. Presbyterian was Cherry Catholic with NutraSweet, etc. But, I believed, each at their core focused on “Thou Shalt NOT”, intolerance, and judgment. It wasn’t until I met and spoke to several Episcopalians that I realized that there are versions of Christianity that really focus more on just making good, moral decisions, and leading a good life. Gee… who knew?
Ultimately, Christianity as a practice or a form of worship can be summed up collectively in my silly little world as “ice cream”. Now personally, I’m more of an apple-pie kinda guy myself, but bear with me for this bizarre analogy. There are many, many different flavors of ice cream out there to give you your fix. You can stick with vanilla, or go for something more exotic. You may want to try Pentecostal Pistachio (full of nuts!), or Episcopalian Tutti-Frutti (obvious, given the latest move in the Episcopalian community). There’s marshmallow Methodist (very airy and extremely fluffy), and Non-Denomenational Heavenly Hash. And to add even more interest, you may want to have that in a waffle-cone, or add sprinkles of other things on top. Ultimately, there are many, many ways of getting your Christian fix. So what I will never understand is why my friend who craves so much more than just vanilla chooses to stick with just that.
Life is too short to suffer-in-silence. One should find a way to enjoy his or her “Sundae” worship!